While I am glad people are discovering a love of reading, as always when something becomes mainstream, problems seem to arise.
Fae romance, and romantasy in general, is really popular and most people’s gateway into reading. Again, I personally don’t care for a certain author who unfortunately shares my initials and I don’t believe people should still support her, but that’s another issue. I want to talk about how these new books and Booktok have warped one of my favorite series and, I believe, one of the best fae books out there.
First off, I will start by saying this book is Young Adult (YA) and while I am all for smut, I don’t write a book off for not having it. This series has enough tension and banter to satisfy me. Some of you might also be surprised to learn that this has a straight romance, not my usual fare these days, but this is my favorite YA series, even over some queer ones.
That being said, my biggest grief with Booktok’s take on this series is that they label it as a enemies-to-lovers romantasy. It is not. It is a political fantasy with a small romantic subplot. It is about a human girl trying to find her place in Elfhame, the land of the fae, and becoming entangled with a power struggle for the throne. Does the youngest prince have a major crush on her? Yes, but romance doesn’t even become a focus until book three so if you are going into it thinking the romance will be the main plot, you will be disappointed.
Next is the fae themselves. Booktok is obsessed with handsome winged-shadow-daddies, but Holly Black is a folklorist, she writes fae how they should be; strange, creepy, mischievous, cruel. As someone deeply in love with mythology and folklore, I love this accurate portrayal of fae and find it more rich and interesting. Unfortunately people learned the main love interest has a tail and suddenly they don’t find him attractive anymore. That might have changed with the rise of monster romance, but I don’t know. The world depicted in this series also has a whimsy reminiscent of traditional fairy tales that some modern readers might find juvenile, but is actually accurate to folklore and traditional fantasy lore. At my core, I will always be a fantasy lover and this series was perfect in that regard.
I feel the real problem with the new mainstream Booktok and the like is people just want the same cookie-cutter story and characters and mark anything different as lesser. It is okay to like what you like, but don’t put down a book just because it is different. My favorite book series, All for the Game, could only have grown to popularity when it did, in 2013 Tumblr era when people had more open minds and just loved and enjoyed what they did without worrying about seeming popular.
I’m sorry if this just seems like a rant, but I’ve been feeling this build watching reading become mainstream, but people only reading the same three series. I try to keep my reading diverse, not just in content, but in genre so I can be inspired by new ideas. Especially in this age of rising AI, we need humans to keep creating our weird little things and sharing them to keep that spark of interest alive.
So go read the Folk of the Air trilogy, along with its novellas; How the King of Elfhame Learned to Hate Stories and A Conspiracy of Charming Monsters: Illustrated Tales from Elfhame, which just came out and I am excited to get my hands on. I haven’t read the sequel duology yet, but am equally excited. If you don’t feel like committing to a series, I would recommend Holly Black’s standalone, The Darkest Part of the Forest, which is set in the same world, just takes place in the human part. (And it has queer representation!)
And above all, read. Read all you can. Support your local libraries and indie bookstores. Reading is resistance.